# Western Tropical Pacific SST and Isotope Data From MD98-2181 During the Holocene #----------------------------------------------------------------------- # World Data Center for Paleoclimatology, Boulder # and # NOAA Paleoclimatology Program #----------------------------------------------------------------------- # NOTE: Please cite original publication, online resource and date accessed when using this data. # If there is no publication information, please cite Investigator, title, online resource and date accessed. # # Online_Resource: http://www.hurricane.ncdc.noaa.gov/pls/paleox/f?p=519:1:::::P1_STUDY_ID:16055 # # Original_Source_URL: ftp://ftp.ncdc.noaa.gov/pub/data/paleo/contributions_by_author/khider2014/khider2014-raw.txt # # Archive: Paleoceanography # #-------------------------------- # Contribution_Date # Date: 2014-02-10 #-------------------------------- # Title: Western Tropical Pacific SST and Isotope Data From MD98-2181 During the Holocene #-------------------------------- # Investigators: Khider, D.; Jackson, C.S.; Stott, L.D. #-------------------- # Description and Notes: # Benthic (Cibicicoides mundulus) foraminifera carbon and oxygen isotopes and planktonic foraminifera (Globigerinoides ruber) Mg/Ca and carbon and oxygen isotopes from a sediment core recovered from the Davao Gulf (South of Mindanao) in the western tropical Pacific in 1998. The data are analyzed to investigate millennial-scale variability in surface and deep water during the Holocene. The record is 10,000-year long. Oxygen and carbon isotopic analyses were performed at the University of Southern California. Isotopic values are reported in delta notation relative to the Vienna PeeBee Belemnite (VPDB) isotopic standard. The Mg/Ca analyses were performed at the University of Southern California. The 14C chemistry was performed at NOSAMS (WHOI) and the University of California Irvine. 14C dates were converted to calendar ages using the Marine09 calibration curve from Reimer et al. (2009). The foraminifera geochemistry was converted from the depth domain to the time domain by using a spline interpolation between 14C dates. Age model uncertainty was assessed through Monte-Carlo simulations. # #-------------------- # Publication # Authors: Khider, D., C.S. Jackson, and L.D. Stott # Journal_Name: Paleoceanography # Published_Title: Assessing millennial-scale variability during the Holocene: a perspective from the western tropical Pacific # Published_Date_or_Year: 2014 # Volume: # Pages: # DOI: 10.1002/2013PA002534 # Abstract: We investigate the relationship between tropical Pacific and Southern Ocean variability during the Holocene using the stable oxygen isotope and magnesium/calcium records of co-occurring planktonic and benthic foraminifera from a marine sediment core collected in the western equatorial Pacific. The planktonic record exhibits millennial-scale sea surface temperature (SST) oscillations over the Holocene of ~0.5°C while the benthic δ18Oc document ~0.10‰ millennial-scale changes of Upper Circumpolar Deep Water (UCDW), a water mass which outcrops in the Southern Ocean. Solar forcing as an explanation for millennial-scale SST variability requires (1) a large climate sensitivity and (2) a long 400-year delayed response, suggesting that if solar forcing is the cause of the variability, it would need to be considerably amplified by processes within the climate system at least at the core location. We also explore the possibility that SST variability arose from volcanic for! cing using a simple red noise model. Our best estimates of volcanic forcing falls short of reproducing the amplitude of observed SST variations although it produces power at low-frequency similar to that observed in the MD81 record. Although we cannot totally discount the volcanic and solar forcing hypotheses, we are left to consider that the most plausible source for Holocene millennial-scale variability lies within the climate system itself. In particular, UCDW variability coincided with deep North Atlantic changes, indicating a role for the deep ocean in Holocene millennial-scale variability. #-------------------- # Publication # Authors: Stott, L., A. Timmermann, and R. Thunell # Journal_Name: Science # Published_Title: Southern Hemisphere and deep-sea warming led to deglacial atmospheric CO2 rise and tropical warming # Published_Date_or_Year: 2007 # Volume: 318 # Pages: 435-438 # DOI: 10.1126/science.1143791 # Abstract: #-------------------- # Publication # Authors: Stott, L., Cannariato, K., Thunell, R., Haug, G.H., Koutavas, A., and Lund, S. # Journal_Name: Nature # Published_Title: Decline of surface temperature and salinity in the western tropical Pacific Ocean in the Holocene epoch # Published_Date_or_Year: 2004 # Volume: 431 # Pages: 56-59 # DOI: 10.1038/nature0293 # Abstract: #-------------------------------- # Funding_Agency: # Funding_Agency_Name: US National Science Foundation # Grant: AGS#1049238 and AGS#1344514 #-------------------------------- # Funding_Agency: # Funding_Agency_Name: USC William M. Keck Foundation Endowed Graduate Fellowship # Grant: #-------------------------------- # Funding_Agency: # Funding_Agency_Name: University of Texas Institute for Geophysics Postdoctoral Fellowship # Grant: #-------------------------------- # Site Information: # Site_Name: MD98-2181 # Location: Western Pacific Ocean # Northernmost_Latitude: 6.45 # Southernmost_Latitude: 6.45 # Easternmost_Longitude: 125.83 # Westernmost_Longitude: 125.83 # Elevation: -2114 #-------------------------------- # Data Collection # Collection_Name: MD98-2181 Raw K14 # Oldest_Year: # Most_Recent_Year: # Time_Unit: # Core_Length; # Notes: Analytical Uncertainty: 0.2mmol/mol (Mg/Ca), 0.14‰ (δ18O, VPDB), 0.1‰ (δ13C, VPDB) #-------------------------------- # Chronology # Supplementary Table S1: AMS results for marine sediment core MD98-2181. The planktonic 14C dates were converted to calendar ages # using the CLAM software (Blauuw et al., 2010) after a reservoir age correction of 74±70 from South Borneo (Southon et al, 2002) # # Gs: G sacculifer, Gr: G. ruber, MB: Mixed Benthics, Cm: C. mundulus. # # Depth Species CAMS# 14Cage±1σ Calendar Age±1σ # 12cm Gs OS-36493 580±110 269±222 # 55cm Gs/Gr OS-37308 815±200 491±395 # 99cm Gs/Gr OS-37292 1010±100 688±205 # 145cm Gs OS-37306 1090±120 742±242 # 201cm MP 90357 1750±15 1389±149 # 238cm Gs OS-36485 1900±100 1551±262 # 351cm Gs/Gr 104528 2575±20 2368±232 # 402cm Gs OS-37289 3960±150 4069±433 # 501cm Gs OS-37303 4070±190 4245±530 # 610cm Gs/Gr 104529 4925±30 5344±216 # 711cm Gs OS-34874 6950±50 7519±153 # 755cm Gs OS-34875 7360±50 7891±193 # 861cm Gs OS-34876 9480±55 10395±175 # 941cm Gs OS-36478 11050±310 12488±803 # 201cm MB 90358 2980±15 # 402cm MB 90359 4430±20 # 751cm Cm OS-55868 8950±50 # 861cm Cm OS-55896 10350±65 #-------------------------------- # Variables # # Data variables follow (have no #) # Variables format: one per line, shortname-tab-9 components: what, material, error, units, seasonality, archive, detail, method, C or N for Character or Numeric data) depth_cm depth ,,,cm,,,,,N Mg/Ca-g.rub-w.v Magnesium Calcium ratio,G. ruber white,,mmol/mol,,Paleoceanography,,,N d18Og.rub-w.v delta 18O,G. ruber white,,per mil VPDB,,Paleoceanography,,,N d13Cg.rub-w.v delta 13C,G. ruber white,,per mil VPDB,,Paleoceanography,,,N d18Oc.mund.v delta 18O,Cibicidoides mundulus,,per mil VPDB,,Paleoceanography,,,N d13Cc.mund.v delta 13C,Cibicidoides mundulus,,per mil VPDB,,Paleoceanography,,,N # Data: # Missing Value: -999.9 depth_cm Mg/Ca-g.rub-w d18Og.rub-w d13Cg.rub-w d18Oc.mund d13Cc.mund notes 1 5.21 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 1 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.30 2.45 2.5 5.04 0.76 -2.83 -999.90 -999.90 3 -999.90 1.53 -2.81 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 4 -999.90 0.90 -2.78 -999.90 -999.90 5 5.10 0.75 -2.64 0.03 2.77 5 -999.90 0.95 -2.93 -999.90 -999.90 6.5 5.04 0.74 -2.85 -999.90 -999.90 7 5.01 0.92 -2.57 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 7 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.27 2.67 8 5.09 0.69 -2.93 -999.90 -999.90 9 -999.90 1.00 -2.80 -0.13 2.65 11 -999.90 1.34 -2.50 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 11 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.05 2.71 11.5 5.23 0.88 -2.50 -999.90 -999.90 12 -999.90 1.35 -2.94 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 12 -999.90 1.04 -2.71 -999.90 -999.90 13 5.17 1.01 -2.69 -0.07 2.82 15 5.30 1.09 -2.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 15 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.06 2.88 16 4.98 1.53 -2.67 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 16 5.29 1.08 -2.60 0.00 2.84 16.5 -999.90 1.04 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 17 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.06 2.89 19 4.70 1.50 -2.98 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 19 5.20 1.11 -2.27 -0.02 2.71 19 -999.90 1.13 -2.60 -999.90 -999.90 21 4.79 1.66 -2.73 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 21 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.00 2.70 22.5 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.08 2.68 23 4.98 0.95 -2.91 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 23 -999.90 0.94 -2.53 0.01 2.77 23 -999.90 0.96 -3.00 -999.90 -999.90 24 5.31 1.28 -3.02 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 25 5.24 0.79 -3.01 -0.15 2.76 27 5.29 1.06 -2.40 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 27 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.00 2.71 28 5.36 1.07 -2.49 0.00 2.62 29 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.04 2.74 30 5.12 1.82 -3.01 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 31 5.30 1.22 -2.60 0.02 2.74 31 -999.90 1.02 -2.51 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 31 4.86 1.05 -2.47 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 31 -999.90 0.69 -2.55 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 31 -999.90 1.05 -2.72 -999.90 -999.90 33 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.58 2.74 34 5.11 1.03 -2.80 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 34 5.04 1.01 -2.56 0.03 2.76 35 -999.90 1.01 -2.72 -0.11 2.61 36 -999.90 1.54 -3.21 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 36 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.06 2.67 37 5.00 0.84 -2.72 -0.09 2.53 38 5.74 1.26 -2.88 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 39 5.00 1.21 -2.64 0.02 2.64 39 -999.90 1.17 -2.69 -999.90 -999.90 41 4.97 1.85 -3.14 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 41 -999.90 0.80 -2.87 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 41 -999.90 0.94 -2.77 0.09 2.75 42.5 -999.90 1.20 -2.78 -999.90 -999.90 43 4.66 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 44 5.01 1.20 -2.78 -0.01 2.64 45 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.25 2.90 46 -999.90 1.18 -3.00 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 47 4.95 0.89 -2.56 0.00 2.78 48 5.40 1.29 -2.95 -0.04 2.78 50 -999.90 1.17 -2.87 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 50 5.39 1.37 -3.14 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 51 4.65 1.01 -2.68 0.04 2.72 52.5 -999.90 1.00 -2.98 -999.90 -999.90 54 4.90 1.10 -2.76 -0.05 2.66 56 4.87 1.93 -2.95 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 56.5 -999.90 0.94 -3.05 -999.90 -999.90 59 4.88 0.86 -2.82 -0.17 2.55 61 5.41 0.95 -3.00 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 61 4.87 0.93 -3.05 -999.90 -999.90 63 -999.90 1.63 -2.81 -0.04 2.72 64 5.14 1.00 -2.57 -0.02 2.71 65 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.32 2.65 66 5.73 1.32 -3.02 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 66 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.02 2.63 66.5 -999.90 1.10 -2.78 -999.90 -999.90 67 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.12 2.61 68 -999.90 0.91 -2.51 -999.90 -999.90 69 4.92 0.85 -2.97 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 69 5.25 0.92 -2.93 -0.09 2.78 71 5.17 1.18 -3.05 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 71 -999.90 0.49 -2.42 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 71 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.18 2.68 72 4.62 1.00 -2.88 -0.02 2.65 74 4.75 1.84 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 75 4.73 1.11 -2.82 -0.07 2.60 75 -999.90 1.08 -2.86 -999.90 -999.90 77 5.19 0.99 -2.89 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 77 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.00 2.63 79 4.97 0.89 -2.99 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 79 5.06 0.14 -3.05 -0.12 2.55 81 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.36 2.75 82 5.22 0.85 -2.87 0.08 2.65 82 -999.90 1.14 -2.96 -999.90 -999.90 83 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.11 2.62 84 5.07 0.97 -2.49 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 85 5.13 -999.90 -999.90 0.01 2.62 86 5.18 1.77 -2.40 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 86 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.03 2.74 87 5.01 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 87 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.17 2.66 87.5 5.16 0.92 -3.00 -999.90 -999.90 89 5.02 1.13 -2.77 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 89 5.12 1.03 -2.80 -0.63 2.51 G. ruber isotope data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 89 -999.90 1.05 -2.95 -999.90 -999.90 91 4.80 2.15 -2.33 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 91 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.21 2.59 92 5.11 1.10 -3.05 0.02 2.65 93 5.06 0.91 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 94 5.05 0.90 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 94.5 4.88 0.84 -2.87 -999.90 -999.90 95 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.21 2.48 96 5.50 1.42 -3.06 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 97 5.06 1.30 -2.92 0.04 2.69 99 -999.90 -0.16 -3.04 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 98.5 4.71 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 99 -999.90 1.66 -2.61 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 99 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.65 2.36 100 4.87 1.14 -2.69 -0.59 2.49 101 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.14 2.48 103 -999.90 1.40 -2.89 0.04 2.53 103.5 5.10 1.05 -3.08 -999.90 -999.90 105 5.67 1.34 -2.94 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 105 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.13 2.65 105.5 5.06 1.36 -2.87 -999.90 -999.90 107 -999.90 1.29 -3.04 -0.72 2.19 108 5.66 1.11 -2.97 -0.04 2.61 109 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.30 2.01 110 5.89 1.18 -3.05 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 110.5 4.99 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 111 4.88 1.45 -2.91 0.11 2.71 111 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.03 2.70 113 4.84 0.90 -3.12 0.00 2.46 113 5.71 1.50 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 115 5.26 1.54 -2.92 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 115.5 -999.90 0.99 -2.91 -999.90 -999.90 117 5.73 0.71 -2.57 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 117 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.03 2.63 118 4.93 1.22 -2.84 -0.20 2.48 118 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.11 2.64 120 5.03 1.36 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 120 5.76 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 120 4.89 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 120.5 -999.90 1.02 -2.99 -999.90 -999.90 121 -999.90 1.24 -2.93 0.29 2.67 123 4.76 0.66 -3.05 -999.90 -999.90 125 4.82 1.22 -3.04 0.00 2.48 G. ruber data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 126 4.78 1.11 -2.87 -0.13 2.78 127 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.05 2.70 129 -999.90 1.06 -2.77 -0.04 2.46 131 5.30 1.21 -3.00 -0.11 2.63 G. ruber data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 133 -999.90 1.11 -2.48 -0.16 2.72 134 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.14 2.58 134 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.00 2.84 135 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.19 2.52 136 -999.90 1.77 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 137 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.11 2.76 138 -999.90 1.08 -2.72 -999.90 -999.90 139 -999.90 1.50 -2.73 -0.08 2.55 140 5.27 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 141 5.35 1.47 -2.83 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 141 -999.90 1.03 -3.06 -0.05 2.84 142.5 -999.90 1.10 -2.98 -999.90 -999.90 143 -999.90 1.10 -2.69 0.04 2.73 143.5 -999.90 1.17 -3.16 -999.90 -999.90 144 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 144.5 -999.90 1.03 -3.05 -999.90 -999.90 145 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.00 2.52 145 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.14 3.00 145.5 -999.90 1.27 -3.15 -999.90 -999.90 146 -999.90 0.52 -2.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 147 4.87 1.24 -2.93 0.15 2.73 148 -999.90 0.73 -2.72 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 149 -999.90 0.81 -3.05 0.04 2.78 151 -999.90 0.41 -3.19 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 151 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.12 2.63 152 5.02 0.89 -3.14 -999.90 -999.90 153 -999.90 1.44 -2.83 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 153 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.11 2.81 153 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.08 2.59 155 -999.90 0.73 -2.76 0.03 2.66 156 -999.90 0.63 -3.29 -999.90 -999.90 157 5.46 1.66 -2.72 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 157 -999.90 1.47 -2.72 0.12 2.66 159 -999.90 0.17 -3.08 -0.07 2.65 159 -999.90 1.24 -2.91 -999.90 -999.90 159 -999.90 0.97 -3.11 -999.90 -999.90 161 4.90 1.62 -2.75 0.01 2.69 161 5.53 1.17 -2.83 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 161 -999.90 0.92 -3.31 -999.90 -999.90 163 -999.90 1.20 -2.77 -0.12 2.57 163 -999.90 0.78 -3.17 -0.17 2.80 165 5.16 1.34 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 165 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.05 2.71 166 5.06 0.85 -2.73 -999.90 -999.90 166 4.90 0.82 -3.24 -999.90 -999.90 167 -999.90 1.51 -3.17 0.01 2.63 169 5.15 0.71 -2.60 -0.13 2.67 169 5.54 1.50 -2.97 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 169 -999.90 0.72 -3.16 -999.90 -999.90 171 -999.90 0.82 -2.60 0.07 2.58 171 -999.90 1.38 -3.01 -999.90 -999.90 172 -999.90 1.14 -2.89 -999.90 -999.90 173 5.82 1.68 -2.67 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 175 4.88 1.51 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 175 5.80 0.78 -3.11 -0.14 2.64 176 5.91 1.42 -3.05 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 177 4.82 0.07 -2.47 -0.08 2.60 177 -999.90 0.95 -2.99 -999.90 -999.90 179 5.60 1.59 -2.73 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 179 5.13 -0.03 -2.55 -0.05 2.60 179 5.44 0.79 -3.17 -999.90 -999.90 181 4.93 1.42 -2.73 0.06 2.58 181 -999.90 1.41 -2.99 -999.90 -999.90 181 -999.90 0.87 -3.08 -999.90 -999.90 182 5.14 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 183 -999.90 1.50 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 183 -999.90 -0.15 -2.71 0.07 2.65 183 -999.90 0.88 -2.94 -999.90 -999.90 184 5.56 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 185 5.28 0.83 -2.73 -0.05 2.60 185 -999.90 0.92 -3.05 -999.90 -999.90 186 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 187 -999.90 1.40 -2.63 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 187 -999.90 0.84 -2.65 -0.05 2.59 187 -999.90 1.49 -2.47 -999.90 -999.90 189 -999.90 1.37 -2.73 -999.90 -999.90 189 -999.90 0.87 -2.78 -999.90 -999.90 191 4.97 1.20 -2.86 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 191 4.85 0.73 -3.14 -0.14 2.52 191 -999.90 0.70 -2.90 -999.90 -999.90 193 -999.90 0.83 -2.93 0.01 2.61 195 5.20 1.40 -2.54 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 195 -999.90 1.32 -2.25 -0.03 2.55 196 -999.90 1.08 -2.58 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 197 -999.90 0.77 -2.95 -0.03 2.67 199 -999.90 1.04 -2.90 -999.90 -999.90 201 5.25 1.53 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 201 -999.90 0.50 -2.89 -0.02 2.63 203 5.70 1.35 -2.77 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 203 -999.90 1.45 -2.81 0.00 2.67 205 5.04 1.26 -2.70 -0.05 2.72 207 5.53 1.60 -2.83 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 207 5.18 1.26 -2.79 0.05 2.60 209 -999.90 0.98 -2.65 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 209 -999.90 1.04 -2.81 -0.02 2.65 209 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.00 2.76 211 5.19 1.37 -2.45 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 211 5.18 1.00 -2.68 -0.07 2.56 211 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.02 2.82 213 5.33 1.18 -2.48 0.04 2.59 215 5.51 1.52 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 215 5.54 1.18 -2.73 0.06 2.56 215 5.17 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 217 5.38 1.15 -2.80 -0.07 2.54 217 5.70 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 219 5.29 1.48 -2.64 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 219 5.23 0.78 -2.92 -0.07 2.57 219 5.28 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 220 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 221 5.28 1.32 -2.72 0.05 2.64 223 5.30 0.99 -2.78 -0.06 2.58 223 -999.90 1.62 -2.76 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 225 -999.90 1.10 -2.55 -999.90 -999.90 226 5.40 1.24 -2.60 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 227 5.72 1.24 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 227 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.01 2.54 229 5.24 1.16 -2.80 -0.01 2.51 231 5.51 1.45 -2.52 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 231 5.18 1.27 -2.91 0.01 2.60 233 4.96 1.22 -2.49 -0.04 2.59 233 5.26 -999.90 -999.90 -0.02 2.64 235 5.31 1.46 -2.74 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 235 5.37 0.71 -2.05 -0.08 2.50 237 4.93 1.11 -2.52 -0.01 2.55 237 5.33 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 238 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 239 5.42 1.51 -2.66 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 239 4.92 0.97 -2.72 -999.90 -999.90 239 5.42 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 241 -999.90 0.95 -2.67 -0.05 2.70 243 -999.90 0.75 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 244 4.94 1.55 -2.51 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 245 -999.90 0.85 -2.52 -0.13 2.51 247 -999.90 1.49 -2.60 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 247 -999.90 0.59 -2.74 -999.90 -999.90 248 4.71 0.99 -2.81 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 249 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.05 2.52 249 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.05 2.74 251 5.33 1.35 -2.63 -0.07 2.60 G. ruber data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 253 -999.90 0.71 -2.36 -0.02 2.60 253 -999.90 1.18 -2.68 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 254 5.09 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 255 -999.90 0.82 -2.88 -999.90 -999.90 257 5.13 1.24 -2.60 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 257 -999.90 0.46 -2.68 -0.02 2.61 257 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.13 2.57 259 -999.90 0.38 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 261 -999.90 1.37 -2.70 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 261 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.04 2.70 261 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.02 2.67 262 5.31 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 263 4.90 1.14 -2.88 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 263 -999.90 0.42 -2.96 -999.90 -999.90 265 -999.90 1.13 -2.89 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 265 -999.90 1.09 -3.14 0.01 2.69 265 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.04 2.64 267 -999.90 0.80 -3.06 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 267 -999.90 0.95 -2.88 -0.12 2.66 269 4.89 0.60 -2.69 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 269 -999.90 0.73 -2.99 0.00 2.67 271 4.98 0.82 -2.65 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 271 -999.90 1.05 -2.78 -999.90 -999.90 273 5.09 1.69 -2.72 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 273 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.02 2.62 273 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.06 2.62 274 -999.90 0.69 -2.90 -999.90 -999.90 275 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.02 2.64 275 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.04 2.62 276 -999.90 0.98 -3.23 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 277 -999.90 1.27 -2.80 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 277 -999.90 1.49 -2.72 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 277 -999.90 1.24 -2.85 -999.90 -999.90 279 4.94 0.60 -2.89 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 279 5.16 0.91 -3.03 0.05 2.72 279 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.07 2.56 281 -999.90 0.58 -3.40 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 281 -999.90 0.97 -2.91 -999.90 -999.90 283 -999.90 0.97 -2.91 0.05 2.68 285 4.77 0.62 -3.06 -0.14 2.72 286 5.02 0.74 -2.81 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 287 -999.90 1.08 -2.76 -999.90 -999.90 289 4.77 0.55 -2.83 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 290 -999.90 0.76 -2.88 -999.90 -999.90 293 -999.90 1.27 -2.85 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 293 -999.90 0.87 -2.99 -999.90 -999.90 295 -999.90 0.95 -2.90 -999.90 -999.90 296 -999.90 0.87 -2.48 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 297 5.00 1.30 -2.93 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 297 4.93 1.07 -3.08 -0.01 2.70 G. ruber isotope data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 299 -999.90 0.95 -2.78 -0.18 2.64 299 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.15 2.61 301 5.06 1.57 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 301 -999.90 1.06 -2.61 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 301 -999.90 0.98 -2.99 -0.11 2.69 303 -999.90 0.86 -2.72 -0.05 2.66 305 -999.90 1.55 -2.63 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 305 -999.90 1.08 -2.77 -0.07 2.76 307 -999.90 1.02 -2.74 -0.16 2.66 308 5.41 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 309 5.27 1.41 -2.68 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 309 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.07 2.67 310 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 311 4.78 0.62 -3.06 -0.12 2.50 313 -999.90 1.19 -2.76 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 313 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.14 2.35 313 -999.90 1.01 -2.66 0.00 2.75 314 5.43 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 315 -999.90 0.76 -2.93 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 315 -999.90 1.09 -2.89 -0.02 2.59 317 5.27 1.39 -2.81 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 317 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.04 2.67 319 5.13 0.86 -2.74 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 319 -999.90 0.84 -3.08 0.08 2.69 321 -999.90 1.46 -2.58 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 321 4.88 1.08 -2.77 -0.08 2.69 321 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -1.20 2.49 323 -999.90 1.12 -2.80 -0.06 2.65 324 5.30 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 325 4.73 1.57 -2.70 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 325 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.05 2.64 326 -999.90 1.34 -2.75 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 327 5.07 0.95 -2.84 -0.01 2.66 329 5.09 1.29 -2.67 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 329 5.13 1.21 -2.94 0.00 2.71 331 5.06 0.50 -2.93 0.03 2.63 331 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -1.01 2.52 333 5.12 1.53 -2.82 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 333 4.95 1.32 -2.52 -0.10 2.71 335 5.24 1.12 -2.66 -0.04 2.64 336 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 337 5.44 1.61 -2.86 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 337 4.96 1.30 -2.75 -0.04 2.70 339 -999.90 1.07 -2.78 0.04 2.58 340 4.79 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 341 4.90 1.36 -3.09 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 341 -999.90 1.18 -2.93 -0.07 2.58 343 -999.90 1.02 -2.72 0.06 2.64 345 4.83 1.44 -2.74 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 345 5.61 0.96 -3.01 0.02 2.80 347 5.42 0.86 -2.84 -0.02 2.64 349 -999.90 1.63 -2.75 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 349 5.47 1.14 -2.92 0.02 2.61 351 5.70 1.64 -2.74 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 351 4.67 0.94 -3.03 -0.09 2.70 353 5.34 1.49 -2.89 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 353 5.00 1.06 -3.05 -999.90 -999.90 355 5.02 1.53 -2.58 0.01 2.68 355 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.00 2.48 357 4.70 1.84 -2.67 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 357 -999.90 1.32 -2.75 0.05 2.66 359 -999.90 1.25 -2.89 -0.03 2.66 360 4.59 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 361 -999.90 1.68 -2.95 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 361 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.03 2.74 361 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.06 2.68 363 -999.90 1.16 -2.94 0.07 2.68 364 5.35 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 365 5.05 1.40 -2.67 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 365 -999.90 1.08 -2.94 0.00 2.44 367 4.71 1.33 -2.76 0.02 2.76 369 5.27 1.39 -2.71 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 369 5.11 0.83 -2.87 0.04 2.65 371 4.95 -0.15 -3.46 -0.07 2.69 371 -999.90 1.33 -2.82 0.12 2.72 373 4.88 1.41 -2.54 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 373 4.85 1.18 -2.77 -0.19 2.71 376 5.09 1.56 -2.75 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 375 5.08 0.62 -2.73 0.02 2.82 377 5.07 1.44 -2.82 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 377 5.34 1.13 -2.73 0.06 2.64 379 5.17 0.98 -2.65 0.03 2.68 379 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.11 2.55 381 4.86 1.41 -2.81 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 381 5.68 1.29 -2.86 -0.10 2.35 381 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.53 2.51 383 -999.90 1.06 -2.90 -0.03 2.65 385 -999.90 1.47 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 385 4.84 1.47 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 385 -999.90 1.08 -2.68 0.08 2.73 387 5.61 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 387 -999.90 1.06 -2.94 0.08 2.62 389 5.01 1.58 -3.04 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 389 5.06 1.08 -3.01 -0.02 2.65 391 5.17 1.11 -2.76 0.07 2.83 393 5.65 1.52 -2.83 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 393 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.05 3.08 393 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.00 2.60 393 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.38 2.41 395 5.24 -999.90 -999.90 0.02 2.96 395 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.11 2.48 397 -999.90 0.96 -2.95 0.03 2.73 G. ruber isotope data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 397 5.34 1.22 -2.92 -999.90 -999.90 399 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.02 2.91 399 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.12 2.59 401 -999.90 1.41 -2.56 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 401 -999.90 1.48 -2.59 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 401 5.08 1.03 -2.48 0.06 2.83 401 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.16 2.59 403 5.25 1.13 -2.41 0.05 2.77 403 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.12 2.59 405 5.55 1.29 -2.67 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 405 4.89 1.38 -2.66 0.02 2.81 405 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.81 2.55 407 5.26 1.44 -2.82 0.07 2.80 407 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.09 2.90 409 -999.90 1.56 -2.69 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 409 4.98 1.28 -2.77 0.26 2.84 411 5.16 1.12 -2.73 0.07 2.78 411 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.75 2.53 413 -999.90 1.37 -2.74 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 413 5.07 0.97 -3.14 0.05 2.62 413 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.03 2.63 415 4.79 0.91 -3.19 -0.73 2.70 415 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.02 2.69 417 5.49 1.59 -2.65 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 417 4.87 1.18 -3.11 -0.49 2.63 417 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.05 2.73 417 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.10 2.60 419 -999.90 1.12 -2.80 0.30 2.64 421 -999.90 1.28 -2.88 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 421 5.39 1.28 -2.88 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 421 4.99 0.90 -2.99 -0.53 2.67 421 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -1.67 2.57 423 5.28 1.27 -2.95 -1.23 2.63 423 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 1.29 2.53 425 -999.90 1.24 -2.49 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 425 5.00 1.15 -2.97 -0.58 2.63 425 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.12 2.57 426 5.44 1.54 -2.67 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 427 5.46 -999.90 -999.90 0.07 2.52 429 5.50 1.54 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 429 5.31 1.30 -2.77 -0.18 2.60 G. ruber isotope data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 431 -999.90 1.00 -2.52 -0.13 2.53 G. ruber isotope data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 433 -999.90 1.80 -2.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 433 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.03 2.67 433 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.03 2.63 435 -999.90 1.41 -2.73 -0.09 2.19 437 5.48 1.44 -2.67 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 437 -999.90 1.03 -2.97 0.04 2.67 441 -999.90 1.33 -2.67 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 441 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.01 2.80 443 -999.90 1.53 -2.79 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 443 5.06 1.53 -2.79 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 443 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.05 2.66 443 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.00 2.58 444 4.98 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 445 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.10 2.69 447 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.06 2.78 447 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -2.14 2.45 448 5.31 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 449 -999.90 0.54 -2.59 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 449 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.09 2.64 451 -999.90 1.38 -3.02 0.11 2.71 452 5.36 1.43 -2.87 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 452 -999.90 1.43 -2.87 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 452 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 453 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.06 2.63 455 -999.90 -999.90 -2.91 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 455 5.64 1.14 -2.81 0.05 2.62 457 5.30 -999.90 -999.90 -0.94 2.53 459 5.49 -999.90 -999.90 -0.08 2.68 461 5.25 1.43 -2.42 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 461 5.40 -999.90 -999.90 0.04 2.56 463 -999.90 1.07 -2.66 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 463 5.61 1.23 -2.53 0.02 2.83 463 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.75 2.80 465 -999.90 1.00 -2.81 0.03 2.54 467 5.29 -999.90 -2.48 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 467 5.47 1.06 -3.19 0.07 2.57 469 -999.90 1.33 -2.09 0.02 2.54 469 -999.90 1.13 -2.80 -999.90 -999.90 471 5.42 -999.90 -2.53 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 471 5.15 1.03 -2.68 0.04 2.65 473 5.33 1.21 -2.82 0.04 2.55 475 5.42 -999.90 -2.79 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 475 4.85 1.11 -2.83 0.09 2.56 475 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.38 2.40 477 5.18 1.27 -2.87 -0.04 2.61 477 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -2.43 2.48 479 5.46 -999.90 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 479 -999.90 0.92 -2.85 -0.03 2.66 481 -999.90 0.90 -2.79 -0.04 2.34 481 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.87 2.46 483 5.10 -999.90 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 483 5.37 0.97 -2.88 0.06 2.56 485 4.97 1.27 -2.82 -0.13 2.43 486 5.08 1.60 -2.75 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 487 -999.90 -999.90 -2.63 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 487 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.25 2.42 489 -999.90 0.98 -2.53 -0.49 2.56 491 -999.90 1.02 -2.80 0.11 2.54 493 5.13 0.79 -2.92 -0.45 2.76 493 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.60 2.57 495 5.23 -999.90 -3.01 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 495 5.70 0.80 -3.34 -0.75 2.79 495 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -1.18 2.57 497 -999.90 1.10 -2.91 0.58 2.81 499 -999.90 -999.90 -3.00 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 499 5.86 -999.90 -999.90 0.07 2.55 501 5.06 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 503 5.77 -999.90 -2.58 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 503 5.23 1.00 -2.60 -999.90 -999.90 505 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.07 2.36 507 5.03 -999.90 -2.91 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 507 -999.90 0.80 -2.73 -0.01 2.52 509 5.34 1.00 -2.36 0.01 2.53 511 5.13 1.12 -2.73 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 511 -999.90 -999.90 -2.55 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 511 -999.90 1.17 -2.81 0.02 2.78 513 -999.90 1.08 -2.82 -0.13 2.46 515 5.06 1.09 -2.48 0.07 2.76 515 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.04 2.57 517 5.15 1.11 -2.69 -0.03 2.67 519 5.16 -999.90 -2.78 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 519 5.19 1.30 -2.90 -0.01 2.58 521 5.11 1.03 -3.11 -0.10 2.55 523 5.16 -999.90 -2.70 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 523 5.07 0.78 -2.96 -0.07 2.39 525 5.03 0.96 -2.85 -0.01 2.75 527 5.09 -999.90 -2.56 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 527 5.04 0.77 -3.45 -999.90 -999.90 527 -999.90 1.22 -3.03 -999.90 -999.90 529 4.93 0.95 -2.88 -0.44 2.16 531 5.29 0.98 -2.90 -999.90 -999.90 533 -999.90 1.17 -2.56 -0.11 2.54 535 5.70 -999.90 -2.66 0.14 2.40 G. ruber data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 535 4.74 -999.90 -999.90 -0.06 2.77 535 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 537 5.23 1.09 -2.69 -0.08 2.46 537 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.00 2.44 539 -999.90 -999.90 -3.00 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 539 5.38 0.75 -2.87 0.02 2.48 539 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.02 2.69 541 -999.90 0.46 -2.94 -0.05 2.57 541 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.07 2.60 543 5.27 -999.90 -2.74 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 543 4.96 0.97 -2.89 -0.01 2.59 543 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.05 2.51 545 -999.90 0.83 -2.88 0.04 2.48 547 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.17 2.64 549 5.27 0.94 -2.80 -0.04 2.55 551 -999.90 1.31 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 551 5.62 0.76 -2.73 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 551 -999.90 0.98 -2.68 -0.04 2.78 553 5.01 1.20 -2.70 -0.13 2.60 555 4.93 1.05 -2.73 0.00 2.65 555 5.87 1.28 -2.59 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 555 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.03 2.72 557 4.91 1.35 -2.70 -0.09 2.65 557 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.02 2.69 559 5.76 1.04 -2.60 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 559 5.06 1.29 -2.71 0.08 2.68 G. ruber isotope data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 559 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 0.22 2.81 561 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.15 2.65 561 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.10 2.68 563 -999.90 1.00 -2.84 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 563 5.02 0.66 -3.45 0.03 2.55 565 5.28 -999.90 -999.90 0.06 2.52 567 5.84 0.98 -2.91 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 567 5.00 1.02 -2.69 -0.12 2.76 569 5.22 0.91 -2.67 -999.90 -999.90 571 -999.90 1.06 -2.80 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 571 5.15 1.36 -2.71 -999.90 -999.90 573 -999.90 1.29 -2.53 -0.10 2.63 575 -999.90 1.06 -2.94 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 575 5.25 1.20 -2.98 -0.08 2.59 577 5.04 1.15 -2.77 -0.18 2.60 579 5.00 1.10 -2.88 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 579 5.01 1.14 -2.62 -0.04 2.76 581 4.91 0.89 -2.95 -0.09 2.77 583 5.38 1.00 -2.52 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 583 4.75 1.10 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 585 4.86 -999.90 -999.90 -0.01 3.08 587 5.28 1.16 -2.48 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 587 5.15 0.89 -3.13 -999.90 -999.90 589 -999.90 0.88 -2.74 -999.90 -999.90 591 -999.90 1.07 -2.59 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 591 5.03 0.88 -2.79 -0.01 2.60 593 -999.90 0.96 -2.62 -0.12 2.72 593 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.13 2.73 595 4.95 1.06 -2.56 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 595 5.36 0.95 -2.63 -999.90 -999.90 597 5.25 1.08 -2.53 -999.90 -999.90 599 5.78 1.01 -2.58 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 599 5.10 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 599 -999.90 0.97 -2.76 -0.29 2.67 601 5.20 -999.90 -2.74 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 601 5.16 0.79 -2.74 -0.06 2.69 603 5.39 1.09 -2.43 -0.24 2.43 605 5.53 -999.90 -2.83 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 605 5.61 0.96 -2.79 -0.10 2.57 607 5.03 0.84 -2.76 -999.90 -999.90 609 -999.90 -999.90 -2.74 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 609 -999.90 0.99 -2.89 -999.90 -999.90 611 5.29 1.90 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 611 4.97 1.19 -2.40 -999.90 -999.90 613 5.44 -999.90 -2.83 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 613 5.48 0.95 -2.97 -0.08 2.66 615 5.17 1.18 -2.91 -0.16 2.75 617 5.65 -999.90 -2.76 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 617 5.17 1.07 -2.71 -0.05 2.61 619 5.36 1.04 -2.78 -999.90 -999.90 621 5.13 -999.90 -2.77 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 621 5.38 0.97 -2.68 -999.90 -999.90 623 5.14 1.00 -2.95 -999.90 -999.90 625 5.81 -999.90 -2.79 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 625 5.45 0.87 -2.86 -999.90 -999.90 627 5.54 1.18 -2.72 -999.90 -999.90 629 5.25 -999.90 -2.88 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 629 5.32 1.12 -2.79 -999.90 -999.90 631 5.55 1.23 -2.60 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 631 5.29 1.10 -2.67 -999.90 -999.90 633 5.11 -999.90 -2.70 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 633 5.60 1.15 -2.32 -0.26 2.72 635 5.17 1.09 -2.67 -0.17 2.66 636 5.36 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 637 5.36 -999.90 -2.72 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 637 5.16 0.64 -3.60 -0.13 2.74 637 -999.90 0.92 -2.57 -0.06 2.62 639 5.57 1.24 -2.56 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 639 5.41 1.23 -2.70 -0.12 2.76 640 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 641 5.26 1.39 -2.69 -0.15 2.66 641 5.52 -999.90 -2.88 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 643 5.35 1.38 -2.42 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 643 4.93 1.26 -2.53 -0.13 2.66 645 5.08 -999.90 -2.64 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 645 5.27 1.14 -2.63 -0.19 2.70 647 5.45 1.04 -2.36 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 647 5.32 1.10 -2.69 -0.11 2.82 649 5.49 -999.90 -2.65 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 649 5.31 1.08 -2.59 -0.16 2.82 649 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.19 2.67 651 5.18 1.13 -2.46 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 651 5.48 0.93 -3.14 -999.90 -999.90 653 5.40 -999.90 -2.52 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 653 5.27 1.19 -2.86 -0.11 2.89 655 5.10 1.24 -2.70 -0.19 2.39 657 -999.90 1.09 -2.79 -0.23 2.62 659 5.58 1.27 -2.71 -0.23 2.67 661 5.56 1.31 -2.72 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 661 5.49 1.11 -2.67 -0.33 2.17 663 5.34 0.95 -2.36 -0.33 2.50 665 5.33 1.22 -2.42 -0.16 2.50 667 5.45 1.17 -2.48 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 667 5.10 0.97 -2.74 -0.14 2.68 669 5.39 1.22 -2.55 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 669 5.28 1.09 -2.67 -0.10 2.53 669 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.14 2.53 671 5.36 1.22 -2.49 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 671 5.34 1.17 -2.60 -0.15 2.47 673 5.66 0.98 -2.55 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 673 5.24 1.08 -2.72 -0.14 2.61 675 5.13 0.51 -2.60 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 675 5.28 0.87 -2.70 -0.18 2.61 677 5.43 -999.90 -2.66 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 677 5.26 0.79 -2.69 -0.21 2.48 679 5.20 1.00 -2.48 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 679 5.11 -999.90 -999.90 -0.21 2.65 681 5.71 0.89 -2.64 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 681 5.18 0.93 -2.71 -0.18 2.57 683 5.31 1.17 -2.49 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 683 5.03 0.67 -2.96 -0.13 2.53 685 5.47 1.24 -2.42 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 685 -999.90 0.76 -2.46 -0.20 2.64 686 5.87 1.26 -2.33 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 687 5.77 0.78 -2.61 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 687 5.31 0.82 -2.88 -0.15 2.63 689 5.77 1.20 -2.73 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 689 5.20 0.71 -2.62 -0.23 2.67 691 5.35 0.87 -2.68 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 691 5.00 0.95 -2.66 -0.18 2.59 693 5.09 1.15 -2.63 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 693 5.28 0.99 -2.83 -0.13 2.84 695 5.30 1.10 -2.57 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 695 4.99 0.95 -2.95 -0.20 2.61 697 5.41 1.10 -2.70 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 697 5.21 0.97 -2.74 -0.13 2.58 699 5.57 0.93 -2.75 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 699 5.36 1.00 -2.82 -0.22 2.65 701 5.42 0.93 -2.41 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 701 -999.90 0.88 -3.00 -0.19 2.64 703 5.57 1.34 -2.61 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 703 5.66 0.89 -2.94 -0.20 2.68 705 5.50 1.09 -2.27 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 705 5.07 1.09 -2.47 -0.18 2.62 707 -999.90 1.04 -3.04 -0.12 2.61 709 5.70 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 709 5.19 1.36 -2.61 -0.16 2.62 711 5.07 1.32 -2.49 -999.90 -999.90 711 5.21 1.45 -2.41 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 713 5.17 0.93 -2.67 -0.17 2.64 715 5.00 0.96 -2.72 -0.19 2.56 717 5.44 -999.90 -2.50 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 717 5.46 1.11 -2.84 -0.23 2.58 719 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.16 2.73 721 5.51 -999.90 -2.52 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 721 4.99 1.05 -2.74 -0.14 2.71 723 5.07 0.85 -2.74 -0.12 2.71 725 5.72 -999.90 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 725 5.23 1.00 -2.95 -0.16 2.70 727 5.20 0.97 -2.65 -0.12 2.74 729 -999.90 0.80 -2.49 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 729 -999.90 0.92 -2.66 -0.19 2.65 731 5.23 0.80 -2.76 -0.15 2.73 733 5.24 0.99 -2.58 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 733 5.10 1.05 -2.70 -0.18 2.65 735 5.35 0.53 -2.77 -0.13 2.66 736 5.78 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 737 5.63 1.10 -2.81 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 737 5.49 1.00 -2.70 -0.21 2.78 739 5.17 1.25 -2.63 -0.18 2.68 741 5.40 0.76 -2.47 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 741 5.06 0.90 -2.78 -0.20 2.74 743 4.83 0.98 -2.68 -0.16 2.57 745 4.92 1.00 -2.70 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 745 5.49 -999.90 -999.90 -0.16 2.73 747 -999.90 0.92 -2.62 -0.12 2.96 747 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.27 2.57 749 5.29 0.98 -2.59 -0.27 2.69 749 5.40 1.08 -2.50 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 751 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.28 2.67 753 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.18 2.68 755 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.14 2.83 755 5.24 1.19 -2.55 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 757 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.26 2.68 759 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.50 2.86 759 5.63 1.01 -2.33 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 761 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.53 2.74 761 5.64 1.29 -2.04 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 763 5.41 1.32 -2.27 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 763 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.23 2.56 765 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.27 2.56 767 5.65 1.24 -2.14 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 767 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.55 2.78 769 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.25 2.60 771 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.33 2.65 771 5.46 1.28 -2.59 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 773 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.34 2.65 775 -999.90 0.97 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 775 -999.90 1.38 -2.50 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 775 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.33 2.42 775 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.32 2.54 777 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.48 2.68 779 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.41 2.82 779 5.45 1.05 -2.30 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 783 -999.90 0.92 -2.36 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 783 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.50 2.66 785 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.32 2.62 786 5.25 1.07 -2.50 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 787 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 789 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.45 2.83 791 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.33 2.73 791 5.43 1.33 -2.18 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 793 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.38 2.77 794 5.45 1.04 -2.46 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 795 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.32 2.69 797 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.23 2.61 799 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.34 2.66 799 5.18 2.03 -2.20 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 801 5.74 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 801 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.34 2.83 803 4.96 0.95 -2.18 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 803 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.35 2.67 805 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.24 2.68 807 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.30 2.71 807 5.29 1.07 -2.41 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 809 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.44 2.47 811 5.48 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 811 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.23 2.75 815 5.35 1.04 -2.41 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 817 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.48 2.77 819 5.54 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 821 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.31 2.78 823 5.71 1.13 -2.32 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 825 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.33 2.58 827 5.53 1.04 -2.44 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 829 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.59 2.70 831 5.91 0.69 -2.58 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 833 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 835 -999.90 0.77 -2.65 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 835 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 836 5.14 1.01 -2.76 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 836 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.54 2.95 839 5.77 0.82 -2.62 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 841 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.59 2.52 843 5.45 0.80 -2.64 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 845 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.44 2.91 847 5.42 0.75 -2.53 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007) 849 -999.90 -999.90 -999.90 -0.29 2.73 851 5.71 0.78 -2.36 -999.90 -999.90 data from Stott et al. (2004, 2007)